Marina Militare--The legal issue(s) about this name.

Discussion in 'Panerai Watches' started by Tanolonco, Jul 25, 2011.

  1. Tanolonco

    Tanolonco

    Bronze Member
    Joined:
    Jul 20, 2011
    Points:
    6
    Posts:
    76
    Likes:
    0
    There is watch, obviously not the real deal, named Marina Militare that is supposedly a "homage" watch except most "homage" watches have the company's name on the dial and do not slap other words on the dial attempting to suggest it is the original--an example would be Debaufre Ocean 1 which is a hommage to the Rolex Submariner. I have read the words, Marina Militare is considered a registered name with Panerai. Is this correct and if so what does it mean legally? We all know there are watches sold by countless sources that have the word, Rolex, on the dial when in fact Rolex had nothing to do with the production of said watch. We call these watches fakes (and rightfully so). My question is this: the watch Marina Militare is not made by Panerai so how is it sold as a "hommage" when in fact they are using a model name? If the words, Marina Militare, are registered then would not this watch, Marina Militare (made by ???) be considered a fake in the legal sense? (the operative word here is legal sense not WIS sense).
  2. Evan614

    Evan614

    Premium Member
    Joined:
    Nov 1, 2010
    Points:
    18
    Posts:
    293
    Likes:
    2
    I think I asked a question about a homage piece and one of the responses was that Panerai sued them and won. So that watch went out of production. Not sure if the company went belly-up.
  3. colemanitis

    colemanitis

    TKF Founder Staff Member
    Joined:
    Jun 21, 2008
    Points:
    26,691
    Posts:
    26,208
    Likes:
    74
    It would be considered a fake.
  4. fstnlgl

    fstnlgl

    Bronze Member
    Joined:
    Feb 18, 2011
    Points:
    6
    Posts:
    48
    Likes:
    0
    Fake. True Panerai collectors know the difference.
  5. BlueB6

    BlueB6

    Bronze Member
    Joined:
    Sep 23, 2008
    Points:
    16
    Posts:
    142
    Likes:
    0
    Not a fake and no, Panerai does not have legal rights to the use of the words Marina Militare on a watch dial. Marina Militiare essentially means Navy (Italian). There are other watches out there with Marina Militare on them that are in fact, issued to Italian Navy personel and can be purchased fully legally by the public.

    If any watch manufacturer has been sued by Panerai, it is for a patent infringement on the crown guard. That's it. The company I think you're referring to above is the Ken Trading Company, which makes the RXW line of watches and specifically the MM20, which was an hommage to a watch OP made in 1950. OP sued them and won and KTC had to cease production.

    However, IIRC, Panerai's patent on the crown lock has expired, leaving others to copy the lock. I'm no patent lawyer, but I remember reading that patents have a finite life, making the inventor the only person (company) legally allowed to use this invention. Once that time frame expires, the market can copy it at will. I think we're in this timeframe.

    FWIW, the RXW never pretended to be a Panerai. No where on the watch did it say Panerai. Sure, fonts were the same, design the same and yes, the crown lock was infringed, but they are great watches (I know... I had one) and IMO are just as good as the PAM127 and actually quite collectible now. I wish I had mine back.

    The only 'fake' Panerai is one that says Panerai on the dial (or elsewhere on the watch), but wasn't made by Panerai. My .02 cents. Anything else is no different than any watch that uses the designs of another. FWIW, don't forget Rolex ripped off the design of the Submariner from Blancpain. No one gets shirty about Rolex ripping them off. ;)
  6. daveathall

    daveathall

    Premium Member
    Joined:
    Aug 10, 2008
    Points:
    128
    Posts:
    11,494
    Likes:
    3
    This was posted on a UK watch forum (The sales part) by its owner.

    Quote;

    Unless it's a genuine Panerai, the sale of any other watch with "Marina Militare" on the dial is not allowed on Sales Corner.

    I've recently been informed by someone in the UK that lawyers acting for Panerai have served him with papers of intended legal action for selling Marina Militare watches on this forum which infringe Panerai's intellectual property rights, namely watches commonly referred to as "MM". Panerai registered the name "Marina Militare" as a trademark in 2005.

    The legal papers served are not a "Cease and Desist" notice, they are "You've infringed our client's intellectual property rights and now you're going to pay". I don't know the legal position concerning selling pre-owned MM on Sales Corner but I'm not willing to take any chances so with immediate effect, the sale of any watch with "Marina Militare" on the dial is prohibited on this forum unless it's a genuine Panerai.
  7. BlueB6

    BlueB6

    Bronze Member
    Joined:
    Sep 23, 2008
    Points:
    16
    Posts:
    142
    Likes:
    0
    Certainly forum management can do as they please, but I'd be surprised if there was any truth to this. OP can't trademark the name of the Italian Navy. But forum management can put in place any rule they deem necessary and if they want to ensure they stay away from legal action, that would be one way. ;)

    Moreover, Timezone.com is the barometer for what is kosher for sales in the watch world and I have seen plenty of watches with marina militare for sale on their sales corner and in fact, I've sold a number of my old hommage watches with marina militare on TZ without issue.
  8. daveathall

    daveathall

    Premium Member
    Joined:
    Aug 10, 2008
    Points:
    128
    Posts:
    11,494
    Likes:
    3
    The quote I posted was from Eddie Platts from TZ-UK, a man that has impecable credentials and not known for knee jerk reactions, as well as producing some very fine watches, including the very rare and famous Dreadnought, he is known for his honest, albeit very blunt demeanour, your quote above "but I'd be surprised if there was any truth to this" has to my knowledge never been used in a sentence that includes the name Eddie Platts, although of course, you were unaware of who originally typed the response I quoted.

    I think you will also find that The Ken Trading company of which you mention in post 5 of this thread is not now trading, rumour has it that it was shut down by a very large watch making company, try googling "The Ken Trading company" see what comes up.

    FWIW, I think that they are very fine watches, although I have not owned one, I have read many reviews. They don't display the Panerai name and so, IMHO can not be described as fake, homage, by all means but not fake.
  9. BlueB6

    BlueB6

    Bronze Member
    Joined:
    Sep 23, 2008
    Points:
    16
    Posts:
    142
    Likes:
    0
    I'm not aware if KTC is still making watches or not, but I do know they continued to make watches long after they got their cease and desist order from OP's lawyers. On the UK forum... that's all fine and good, but I find it really hard to believe OP trademarked the name of the Italian Navy when the Navy themselves have contracted a company to produce watches branded as Marina Militare, right on the dial, for distribution to their own sailors/officers as well as allowing the company to sell to the public. These are quartz watches and OP was dumped as a supplier of watches years ago because they are too costly for gov't purchases for their service men/women. If OP owned the trademark to Marina Militare, then this watch company would be in litigation, as would the Italian Navy. I'm sure OP can't successfully sue the Italian Navy, although the Navy could certainly sue OP and win hands down, if they so chose, because OP is benefiting financially from the use of their name. ;)

    FWIW, companies try to trade mark a lot of things they think are their own and important to brand identity. More often than not, they fail. Maybe this forum did get a letter but because OP was trying to trade mark that phrase regardless of success or failure in court. Years ago here in Canada, Molson Canadian tried to trade mark the use of water droplets on their packaging. Naturally, it was disallowed. Just an example I can think of off the top of my head of a company trying to gain ownership of a phrase/image and failing.

    Regardless, I'm quite certain OP does not own the sole rights to use Marina Militare. As I said, they used to sue based on the crown lock/guard, but that's all.
  10. daveathall

    daveathall

    Premium Member
    Joined:
    Aug 10, 2008
    Points:
    128
    Posts:
    11,494
    Likes:
    3
    They got a cease and desist from OP and now they don't exist? You seem to have your opinion John, mine differs. :cheers:
  11. BlueB6

    BlueB6

    Bronze Member
    Joined:
    Sep 23, 2008
    Points:
    16
    Posts:
    142
    Likes:
    0
    No worries Dave. :cheers:
  12. avatar1

    avatar1

    TKF Newbie
    Joined:
    Apr 24, 2011
    Points:
    1
    Posts:
    2
    Likes:
    0
    Can't be due to the Marina Militare designation, cause the current "official" timekeeper of the Italian Navy also bears it, of course:

    http://www.mmt500.com/index.asp?sezione=1

    So, banning any watch that is not a Panerai and says "Marina Militare" is somewhat... short sighted.
  13. Archer

    Archer

    Silver Member
    Joined:
    Mar 15, 2011
    Points:
    38
    Posts:
    3,316
    Likes:
    2
    I don't know the details of this, but a trademark is quite different from a patent. Trademarks do not run out, and that is what the crown protector is - trademarked. Regarding the Marina Militaire name, it can also be trademarked (lots of things you wouldn't think could be, can be). That does not make it something that no one else can use, but simply something they would have to get permission from the trademark owner to use.

    Again, I don't know the specifics here, but I think it is possible to trademark this name and have it appear (legally) on other products.

    Cheers, Al
  14. Richard44

    Richard44

    Bronze Member
    Joined:
    Jan 18, 2014
    Points:
    19
    Posts:
    4
    Likes:
    0
    A trademark is indeed much different than a patent. A patent is based on a new invention or process. A trademark is some non-engineered or design element. The Coke bottle "shape" is subject to a trademark. The problem for Panerai is that its lever/crown lock and sealing by pressure idea was patented and clearly an engineering concept. It was not and is not a design concept. The shape of the crown lock might seem at first to be entirely optional, of course, but yet, it is round and places the pivot point for the lever right where it would optimally be. The half-circle is an effective shape in that use for a variety of engineering and practical reasons, not just design reasons. Consider for a moment a pivot point for the lever in the same place but held by a crown guard with protruding, sharp, and pointy edges: Instead of a half circle, a half star, and made of stainless steel. Sharp and painful to wear, and totally the opposite of functional for a watch of any sort, let alone a dive watch. But it would be a design or fashion element. Instead the circle design is the one that was engineered and patented for purposes of function. So the shape is not purely or even mainly a design issue.

    My point is that, as noted above by others, the Panerai people obviously want to maintain the exclusivity of the design and have attempted to convert an expired patent into a trademark, and then used intimidation wherever possible to get other companies to stop using the design. So far as I know there has been no court test of these claims, simply threats by a well funded luxury brand. I am not suggesting that making a "fake" or counterfeit Panerai (one that attempts to pass as a Panerai) is either a good or even legitimate thing to do, only that I doubt very much that the designed shape of the crown guard is itself the proper subject of a trademark. It was an aspect of the engineered crown lock system.

    As for the name Marina Militare, I have my doubts about that as well, but I have not researched the issue.

    If anyone here has reference to a trademark case that Panerai won on the crown guard claims and issue I would be very interested in seeing it. Otherwise all we are talking about is the effectiveness of intimidation by a large company against smaller ones.
  15. forsiningwatch

    forsiningwatch

    Bronze Member
    Joined:
    Jun 6, 2016
    Points:
    132
    Posts:
    60
    Likes:
    0
  16. dongdong8

    dongdong8

    TKF Newbie
    Joined:
    Jun 19, 2018
    Points:
    388
    Posts:
    194
    Likes:
    0
    20181121 orf
    cleveland cavaliers jersey
    nike cortez
    real madrid jersey
    nike revolution
    pandora charms
    michael kors outlet
    moncler outlet
    ray ban sunglasses
    ray ban sunglasses
    mizuno running shoes
    ugg outlet
    christian louboutin outlet
    coach outlet
    michael kors outlet
    moncler outlet
    canada goose outlet
    canada goose coats
    fitflops sale clearance
    toms shoes
    ugg outlet
    nba jerseys
    michael kors outlet
    ugg boots
    rockets jerseys
    ray ban sunglasses
    jordan shoes
    canada goose jackets
    pandora charms
    uggs
    toms shoes
    polo ralph lauren
    red bottom shoes
    polo ralph lauren
    mont blanc pens
    canada goose coats
    nike foamposite
    football shirts
    canada goose parka
    fila shoes
    san francisco 49ers jerseys
    coach outlet
    ubiq shoes
    true religion jeans
    birkenstock sandals
    canada goose outlet
    ugg outlet
    chelsea jersey
    prada sunglasses
    cheap jordans
    prada outlet
    five fingers shoes
    polo outlet
    fitflops outlet
    hermes outlet
    gucci outlet
    christian louboutin outlet
    canada goose outlet
    supreme clothing
    gucci outlet
    canada goose outlet
    ugg outlet
    ralph lauren polo shirts
    michael kors outlet
    michael kors outlet
    kobe 9
    coach outlet
    pandora charms
    coach outlet online
    pistons jerseys
    off white
    longchamp outlet
    michael kors outlet online
    kate spade outlet
    supra shoes
    tory burch outlet
    wizards jerseys
    air jordan shoes
    jordan shoes
    coach outlet online
    uggs outlet
    coach outlet
    coach outlet online
    supreme clothing
    michael kors outlet
    michael kors outlet
    pandora charms
    adidas nmd
    tory burch outlet
    adidas outlet
    supreme clothing
    dolce and gabbana
    true religion jeans
    palladium boots
    ferragamo outlet
    pandora outlet
    cartier jewelry
    christian louboutin outlet
    canada goose jackets
    ray ban sunglasses
    ugg outlet
    moncler outlet
    pandora charms
    canada goose outlet
    canada goose jackets
    mbt shoes
    malone souliers mules
    red bottom shoes
    canada goose outlet
    ugg boots
    coach outlet online
    moncler outlet
    balenciaga sneakers
    cheap jerseys
    polo ralph lauren
    gucci outlet
    coach outlet
    ralph lauren pas cher
    christian louboutin outlet
    michael kors handbags
    canada goose jackets
    jazz jerseys
    christian louboutin outlet
    uggs outlet
    polo ralph lauren
    adidas trainers
    polo outlet
    michael kors outlet
    michael kors outlet
    balenciaga sneakers
    light up shoes
    true religion outlet
    heat jerseys
    undefeated clothing
    pandora
    mulberry handbags
    swarovski outlet
    ugg outlet
    nike free
    coach outlet
    true religion outlet
    off-white
    kate spade outlet
    minnetonka outlet
    red bottom shoes
    ugg outlet
    air max 97
    suicoke sandals
    burberry outlet
    polo ralph lauren
    longchamp handbags
    michael kors outlet
    oakley sunglasses
    louboutin pas cher
    belstaff jackets
    keen shoes
    ferragamo shoes
    canada goose jackets
    fitflops sale
    oakley sunglasses
    mcm outlet
    cheap jerseys
    coach outlet
    ugg boots
    ugg outlet
    true religion jeans
    kate spade outlet
    uggs outlet
    hermes birkin
    cheap jerseys
    michael kors outlet
    camel shoes
    gucci outlet
    christian louboutin store
    canada goose jackets
    san antonio spurs jerseys
    coach outlet
    ugg outlet
    longchamp handbags
    air jordan 4
    vans shoes
    ugg boots
    mulberry handbags
    ysl outlet
    michael kors outlet
    michael kors handbags
    michael kors outlet
    michael kors outlet
    michael kors outlet
    hornets jerseys
    coach outlet
    ferragamo outlet
    nba jerseys
    christian louboutin shoes
    pandora jewelry
    cheap football shirts
    ferragamo outlet
    columbia sportswear
    michael kors outlet
    celtics jerseys
    coach outlet online
    michael kors outlet
    ugg outlet
    ugg outlet
    swarovski outlet
    pandora charms
    kate spade outlet
    scarpe mbt
    air max 1
    true religion jeans
    birkenstock outlet
    ugg outlet
    michael kors outlet clearance
    coach factory outlet
    coach outlet
    canada goose jackets
    soccer shoes
    burberry outlet
    coach outlet
    true religion jeans
    canada goose jackets
    moncler outlet
    christian louboutin outlet
    christian louboutin shoes
    pelicans jerseys
    ferragamo outlet
    ugg boots
    ugg outlet
    saucony shoes
    uggs outlet
    red bottom shoes
    suns jerseys
    warriors jerseys
    ray ban sunglasses
    michael kors
    kappa clothing
    north face jackets
    true religion jeans
    knicks jerseys
    air jordan retro
    ugg boots
    michael kors outlet
    ugg boots
    uggs outlet
    coach outlet
    nike dunks
    nike blazer pas cher
    cheap nfl jerseys
    coach outlet
    fitflops sale clearance
    north face jackets
    gucci handbags
    hermes belt
    canada goose outlet
    ugg outlet
    barbour jackets
    yeezy boost 350
    new balance shoes
    true religion jeans
    tory burch outlet
    canada goose jackets
    adidas crazy
    canada goose outlet
    miu miu handbags
    kate spade outlet
    canada goose outlet
    michael kors handbags
    uggs outlet
    toms shoes
    coach outlet
    coach outlet online
    pacers jerseys
    chrome hearts sunglasses
    christian louboutin outlet
    ray ban outlet
    pandora jewelry
    moncler outlet
    coach handbags
    ugg boots
    cavaliers jerseys
    ralph lauren pas cher
    pandora charms
    cheap nfl jerseys
    air force 1
    stussy clothing
    supreme clothing
    ray ban sunglasses
    coach handbags
    mbt shoes
    pandora outlet
    reebok outlet store
    ugg boots
    uggs outlet
    cheap nhl jerseys
    ugg outlet
    ugg boots clearance
    michael kors wallets
    marc jacobs outlet
    ugg boots clearance
    ugg outlet
    canada goose outlet
    canada goose outlet
    ugg outlet
    cazal sunglasses
    air jordan 4
    76ers jerseys
    tods outlet
    nike factory outlet
    coach outlet
    nike shoes
    tory burch outlet
    dansko shoes
    wellensteyn jackets
    ugg outlet
    michael kors outlet
    longchamp outlet
    kobe shoes
    tory burch outlet
    mbt shoes
    mulberry handbags
    jordan shoes
    oakley sunglasses
    coach factory outlet
    fitflops shoes
    nike revolution
    canada goose outlet
    adidas nmd
    mulberry bags
    ecco shoes
    lebron james shoes
    coach outlet online
    christian louboutin outlet
    coach outlet
    ugg outlet
    canada goose jackets
    dc shoes
    jordan shoes
    ray ban sunglasses
    polo outlet
    indianapolis colts jerseys
    ugg boots
    moncler jackets
    canada goose outlet
    stephen curry shoes
    van cleef & arpels jewelry
    mishka clothing
    coach outlet
    polo ralph lauren
    cheap jordans
    ugg outlet
    clarks shoes
    canada goose outlet
    uggs outlet
    michael kors outlet
    nfl jerseys wholesale
    manolo blahnik outlet
    longchamp solde
    ugg boots
    true religion outlet
    mulberry bags
    moncler outlet
    le coq sportif shoes
    canada goose coats
    ugg boots
    canada goose outlet
    polo shirts
    oakley sunglasses
    kate spade outlet
    true religion jeans
    thunder jerseys
    true religion uk
    ugg outlet
    polo ralph lauren
    longchamp pliage
    oakley sunglasses
    ralph lauren polo shirts
    nba jerseys
    under armour outlet
    canada goose outlet
    nike lunarglide
    swarovski outlet
    tory burch outlet
    longchamp bags
    nike air max 2015
    michael kors outlet
    canada goose coats
    ugg outlet
    christian louboutin outlet
    nets jerseys
    michael kors outlet
    bottega veneta outlet
    air jordan 3
    chicago blackhawks jerseys
    michael kors outlet
    yeezy boost
    canada goose jackets
    christian louboutin outlet
    nike shoes
    fitflops
    jack wolfskin
    canada goose jackets
    hawks jerseys
    chrome hearts outlet
    nike shoes
    fitflops sale clearance
    nike outlet
    cheap jordans
    canada goose outlet
    coach outlet
    ugg outlet
    canada goose outlet
    mulberry outlet
    swarovski crystal
    pandora outlet
    nobis outlet
    air huarache
    longchamp outlet
    ugg outlet
    spurs jerseys
    coach outlet online
    mulberry outlet
    mulberry handbags
    uggs outlet
    cheap jordans
    michael kors outlet
    ugg outlet
    polo ralph lauren
    uggs outlet
    canada goose jackets
    polo ralph lauren
    coach outlet
    canada goose outlet
    chrome hearts outlet
    nuggets jerseys
    lakers jerseys
    coach outlet
    kings jerseys
    montblanc pens
    longchamp solde
    ugg boots
    celine outlet
    michael kors outlet
    michael kors handbags
    ray ban sunglasses
    fitflops
    air max 90
    adidas ultra boost
    lakers store
    barcelona jersey
    oakley sunglasses
    uggs outlet
    raptors jerseys
    moncler outlet
    cheap jordans
    polo ralph lauren
    baltimore ravens jerseys
    nike air force 1
    canada goose coats
    michael kors
    coach outlet
    pandora charms sale clearance
    coach outlet
    polo outlet
    adidas wings
    fred perry polo shirts
    y3 shoes
    herve leger outlet
    reebok trainers
    air max 90
    north face jackets
    links of london
    pandora outlet
    bulls jerseys
    ugg outlet
    air jordan shoes
    ralph lauren outlet
    air max 2017
    mont blanc pens
    manchester united jersey
    christian louboutin outlet
    ray ban sunglasses
    tory burch outlet
    soccer jerseys
    kate spade outlet
    nike outlet
    air jordan release dates
    ugg boots clearance
    ferragamo outlet
    true religion outlet
    houston texans jerseys
    moncler jackets
    cheap jordans
    ugg outlet
    soccer jerseys
    jordan shoes
    canada goose outlet
    uggs outlet
    kate spade outlet
    adidas outlet
    kevin durant shoes
    michael kors outlet
    air max 90
    cheap mlb jerseys
    jeep shoes
    jordan shoes
    cheap snapbacks
    ugg outlet
    air max
    tory burch outlet
    ugg outlet
    canada goose outlet
    canada goose outlet
    oakley sunglasses
    grizzlies jerseys
    pandora jewelry
    trailblazers jerseys
    coach outlet online
    canada goose jackets
    ugg outlet
    ugg boots
    coach handbags
    magic jerseys
    kobe bryant shoes
    coach outlet store online
    michael kors outlet clearance
    golden goose sneakers
    mulberry handbags
    ugg outlet
    yeezy boost
    michael kors outlet
    red bottom shoes
    fitflops sale
    adidas uk
    swarovski outlet
    michael kors outlet
    ugg boots
    pandora charms
    givenchy handbags
    tory burch handbags
    nike shoes
    giuseppe zanotti outlet
    uggs outlet
    ugg outlet
    ugg boots
    cheap jordans
    polo outlet
    swarovski crystal
    jimmy choo shoes
    prada shoes
    salomon shoes
    oakley sunglasses
    ray ban sunglasses
    burberry outlet
    bvlgari jewelry
    ed hardy clothing
    ferragamo shoes
    louboutin shoes
    christian louboutin outlet
    coach outlet
    michael kors handbags
    michael kors
    ugg outlets
    canada goose outlet
    nhl jerseys
    ray ban sunglasses
    jordan shoes
    denver broncos jerseys
    air jordan 12
    pandora charms
    longchamp handbags
    puma outlet
    true religion jeans
    kate spade outlet
    ugg boots
    basketball shoes
    coach outlet
    nike shoes
    nfl jersey wholesale
    nike presto
    lacoste polo shirts
    michael kors outlet
    clippers jerseys
    canada goose
    yeezy boost
    ugg outlet
    michael kors outlet online
    ugg outlet
    canada goose
    nhl jerseys
    true religion jeans
    lacoste soldes
    polo ralph lauren
    nike tennis
    pandora charms
    valentino outlet
    simulation shoes
    ralph lauren polo
    coach factory outlet
    golden state warriors jerseys
    coach outlet
    lakers jerseys
    mavericks jerseys
    dior outlet
    kate spade outlet
    world cup jerseys
    canada goose outlet
    visvim shoes
    hermes outlet
    air huarache
    coach outlet
    coach canada
    michael kors outlet
    canada goose outlet
    merrell shoes
    moncler outlet
    canada goose jackets
    coach outlet
    cheap jordans
    converse shoes
    uggs outlet
    nike roshe one
    polo ralph lauren
    ralph lauren polo shirts
    bucks jerseys
    michael kors
    ugg outlet
    true religion jeans
    christian louboutin
    pandora charms
    christian louboutin outlet
    michael kors outlet
    polo ralph lauren
    tory burch outlet
    oakley sunglasses
    ugg boots
    christian louboutin outlet
    pandora charms
    nike store
    michael kors outlet
    coach outlet
    cheap mlb jerseys
    futbol baratas
    harden shoes
    asics shoes
    coach outlet online
    timberwolves jerseys
    canada goose outlet
    cheap jordans
    coach outlet
    burberry outlet

    20181121